A complication of the rotator cuff with superior humeral paralyses: a myth of the deltoid muscle and the mechanics of the humeroscapular joint

Authors

  • Oleg Prudnikov
  • Yevgeny Prudnikov
  • Dmitriy Prudnikov

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15674/0030-598720092108-116

Keywords:

rotator cuff, diagnosis, treatment

Abstract

The authors examined 97 different damages in the shoulder joint region, including neurological, traumatic and mixed ones. It was revealed that isolated “axillary paralysis” (12 cases) did not cause any motor disturbances, except for inconstant weakness of extension (retroversion) and internal rotation of the arm, and preservation of the suprascapular nerve ensured active movements of the humeroscapular joint even in total brachial plexitis. It turned out that in case of deltoid muscle paralysis even a partially damaged rotatory cuff was sometimes able to abduct the arm. Isolated suprascapular paralysis resulted in a complete loss of function of the humeroscapular joint. Operations were made on 71 patients with complete or partial ruptures of the rotatory cuff, complicated by “axillary paralysis” separately or as by a component of brachial plexitis (including 40 cases of the so-called “terrible triad” of the shoulder joint). Surgical restoration of the rotatory cuff made it possible to receive 58 excellent and good results, including 7 patients, whose deltoid muscle paralysis proved to be irreversible. On the basis of their results the authors drew a conclusion that the rotatory cuff played the leading part in movements of the humeroscapular joint, the supraspinous muscle and suprascapular nerve serving as keys to diagnosis of superior brachial paralyses.

References

  1. Бойчев Б. Оперативная ортопедия и травматология / Б. Бойчев, Б. Конфорти, К. Чоканов. — София: Медицина и физкультура, 1962. — 832 с.
  2. Мовшович И.А. Оперативная ортопедия / И.А. Мовшович. — Москва: «Медицина», 1994. — 446 с.
  3. Прудников О.Е. К вопросу дифференциальной диагностики поражений вращающей манжеты плеча и неврологических расстройств в области плечевого сустава / О.Е. Прудников // Журнал невропатологии и психиатрии им. С.С. Корсакова. — 1992. — Т. 92, №3. — С. 19–23.
  4. Прудников О.Е. Подкрыльцовый паралич и движения в плечевом суставе / О.Е. Прудников // Травматология и ортопедия России. — 1995. — №2. — С. 31–33.
  5. Прудников Е.Е. Хирургическое лечение «невосстановимых» разрывов вращающей манжеты плеча / Е.Е. Прудников, О.Е. Прудников, Д.О. Прудников // Политравма. — 2007. — №3. — С. 19–26.
  6. Прудников Д.О. Перелом большого бугорка плечевой кости / Д.О. Прудников, О.Е. Прудников, Е.Е. Прудников // Политравма. — 2007. — №3. — С. 27–36.
  7. Прудников О.Е. Ятрогенные повреждения вращающей манжеты плеча / О.Е. Прудников, Е.Е. Прудников, Д.О. Прудников // Политравма. — 2007. — №3. — С. 60–68.
  8. Топическая диагностика заболеваний нервной системы: рук. для врачей / A.A. Скоромец, A.П. Скоромец, T.A. Скоромец. — 5-е изд. — Санкт-Петербург: Политехника, 2004. — 398 c.
  9. Tриумфов A.В. Топическая диагностика заболеваний нервной системы / A.В. Tриумфов. — Москва: Медицина, 1996. — 259 с.
  10. Чаклин В.Д. Основы оперативной ортопедии и травматологии / В.Д. Чаклин. — Москва: Медицина, 1964. — 738 c.
  11. Aldridge J.M. III. Combined pectoralis major and latissimus dorsi tendon transfer for massive rotator cuff deficiency / J.M. III Aldridge, T.S. Atkinson, W.J. Mallon // J. Shoulder Elbow Surg. — 2004. — Vol. 13, 6. — P. 621–629.
  12. Alnot J.-Y. Indications and therapeutic perspectives: Traumatic brachial plexus injuries / J.-Y. Alnot and A.O. Narakas [editors]. — Paris: Expansion Scientifique Française, 1996. — P. 94–109.
  13. Alnot J.-Y. Retro and infra clavicular lesions.: Traumatic brachial plexus injuries / J.-Y. Alnot and A.O. Narakas [editors]. — Paris: Expansion Scientifique Française, 1996. — P. 202–211.
  14. Alnot J.-Y., Valenti P.H. Surgical Reconstruction of the Axillary Nerve / M. Post, B.F. Morrey, and R.J. Hawkins [editors]. — Surgery of the Shoulder. St Louis: Mosby Year Book, 1990. — P. 330–333.
  15. Bigliani L.-U. Operative repair of massive rotator cuff tears: Long-term results / L.-U. Bigliani, F.A. Cordasco, S.J. McIlveen, E.S. Musso // Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery. — 1992. — Vol. 1. — P. 120–130.
  16. Böhler L. Die Technik der Knochenbruchbehandlung / L. Böhler. — 12-13 Aufgabe. Erganzungsband. Maudrich, Wien-Münster-Bern, 1977. — P. 2616–2629.
  17. Complete palsies through supraclavicular lesions. 1. Surgical possibilities and results / C. Bonnard, Y. Allieu, J.-Y. [et al.]: Traumatic brachial plexus injuries / J.-Y. Alnot and A.O. Narakas [editors]. — Paris: Expansion Scientifique Française, 1996. — P. 126–155.
  18. Bonnel F. L’épaule musculaire (de l’anatomie à la biomécanique): Epaule et médicine de rééducation / F. Bonnel [sous la direction de L. Simon]. — Paris: Masson, 1984. — P. 2–7.
  19. Bonnel F. Le concept biomécanique de l’épaule. Cahiers d’enseignement de la SOFCOT / F. Bonnel. — Conférences d’enseignement, 1993. — P. 1–16.
  20. Bonnel F. Articulation scapulo-humérale (anatomie et biomécanique): L’epaule. L’épaule dégénerative, l’épaule traumatique, l’épaule du sportif. Diagnostic — Rééducation — Chirurgie — Arthroscopie / [sous la direction de F. Bonnel, F. Blotman et M. Mansat]. — Paris: Springer Verlag, 1993. — P. 23–51.
  21. Brown T. Rotator cuff tears and associated nerve injuries / T. Brown, P. Newton, S Steinmann [et al.] // Orthopaedics. — 2000. — Vol. 23. — P. 329–332.
  22. Codman E.A. Rupture of the Supraspinatus Tendon / E.A. Codman // Surg Gynecol Obstet. — 1931. — Vol. 52. — P. 579–586.
  23. Codman E.A. The Shoulder. Rupture of the Supraspinatus Tendon and Other Lesions in or about the Subacromial Bursa / E.A. Codman. — Boston: Thomas Todd Company; 1934. — 513 c. (Reprint of 1984).
  24. Codman E.A. Rupture of the Supraspinatus / E.A. Codman // American Journal of Surgery. — 1938. — XLII, №3. — P. 603–626.
  25. Comtet J.-J. Physiologie des muscles élévateurs de l’épaule / J.-J. Comtet, Y. Auffray // Rev. Chir. Orthop. — 1970. — Vol. 56. — P. 108–112.
  26. Dehne E. Active Shoulder Motion in Complete Deltoid Paralysis / E. Dehne, R.M. Hall // J. Bone Jt. Surg. — 1959. — Vol. 41-A. — P. 745–748.
  27. Duchenne de Boulogne G.B.A. Physiologie des mouvements démontrée à l’aide de l’expérimentation électrique et de l’observation clinique, et applicable à l’étude des paralysies et des déformations / G.B.A. Duchenne de Boulogne. — Paris: Baillère G.B, 1867.
  28. Duchenne de Boulogne G.B.A. Physiology of Motion / E.B. Kaplan [translator and editor]. — Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott Company, 1949.
  29. Gerber C. Massive rotator-cuff tears: European Instructional Course Lecture, 1997. — №3. — P. 85–89.
  30. Gonzalez D. Concurrent Rotator-Cuff Tear and Brachial Plexus Palsy Associated with Anterior Dislocation of the Shoulder / D. Gonzalez, R.A. Lopez // J. Bone Jt. Surg. — 1991. — Vol. 73-A, №4. — P. 620–621.
  31. Goubier J.-N. Anterior dislocation of the shoulder with rotator cuff injury and brachial plexus palsy. A case report / J.-N. Goubier, L.-D. Duranthon, E. Vandenbussche [et al.] // J. Shoulder Elbow Surg. — 2004. — Vol. 13, №3. — P. 362–363.
  32. Groh G.I. The terrible triad: Anterior dislocation of the shoulder associated with rupture of the rotator cuff and injury to the brachial plexus / G.I. Groh, C.A. Rockwood // J. Shoulder Elbow Surg. — 1995. — Vol. 4, №1, part 1. — P. 51–53.
  33. Güven O. Concomitant rotator cuff tear and brachial plexus injury in association with anterior shoulder dislocation: unhappy triad of the shoulder / O. Güven, Z. Akbar, S. Yalçın, // J. Orthop. Trauma. — 1994. — Vol. 8. —P. 429–430.
  34. Güven O. “Terrible triad” or “Unhappy triad”? / O. Güven // J. Shoulder Elbow Surg. —1995. — Vol. 4, №4. — P. 318.
  35. Hertel R. The deltoid extension lag sign for diagnosis and grading of axillary nerve palsy / R. Hertel, S.M. Lambert, F.T. Ballmer // J. Shoulder Elbow Surg. — 2004. — Vol. 7, №2. — P. 97–99.
  36. Imhoff A.B. An Atlas of Shoulder Arthroscopy / A.B. Imhoff, J.B. Ticker, F.H. Fu. — London: Martin Dunitz, 2003. — 384 с.
  37. Inman V.T. Observations on the Function of the Shoulder Joint / V.T. Inman, M.Saunders, L.C. Abbot // J. Bone Jt. Surg. — 1944. — XXVI. — P. 1–30.
  38. Johnson J.R. The Early Complications of Anterior Dislocation in the Middle Aged and Elderly Patient / J.R. Johnson,J.I.L. Bayley // Ian Bayley and Lipmann Kessel [editors]. — Shoulder Surgery. Springer-Verl.: Berlin, 1982. — P. 79–83.
  39. Kay S.P. Acute Tear of the Rotator Cuff Masked by Simultaneous Palsy of the Brachial Plexus / S.P. Kay, J. Yaszemsky, Ch.A. Rockwood // J. Bone Jt. Surg. — 1988. — V. 70-A. — P. 611–612.
  40. Klawans H.L. Neurologic Aspects of the Shoulder / H.L. Kla-wans, J.L. Topel // The Shoulder. Surgical and Nonsurgical Management / [Ed. by Melvin Post]. — Second edition. Lea & Febiger: Philadelphia, 1988. — P. 154–186.
  41. Kruekarnchana P. Shoulder function after subtotal excision of the deltoid muscle and of the deltoid and infraspinatus muscles in extra-abdominal desmoid tumor: A long-term follow-up in two cases / P. Kruekarnchana, K. Suzuki, H. Fukuda // J. Shoulder Elbow Surg. — 2004. — Vol. 13. — P. 119–122.
  42. Lech O. Trapezius muscle transfer to the proximal humerus for the treatment of paralytic deltoid due to brachial plexus lesion: XIV Congreso de SLAHOC. — Santiago de Chile 6-8, de Agosto, 2008.
  43. Markhede G. Shoulder function after deltoid muscle removal / G. Markhede, J. Monastyrski, B. Stener // Acta Orthop. Scand. — 1985. — Vol. 56. — P. 242–244.
  44. McMahon P.J. Shoulder muscle forces and tendon excursions during glenohumeral abduction in the scapular plane / P.J. McMahon, R.E. Debski, W.O. Thompson // J. Shoulder Elbow Surg. — 1995. — Vol. 4. — P. 199–208.
  45. Nakatsuchi Y. Nerve grafting for shoulder weakness / M.S. Watson [editor]. Surgical Disorders of the Shoulder. — Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 1991. — P. 627–644.
  46. Narakas A.O. Lésions du nerf axillaire et lésions associées du nerf supra-scapulaire / A.O. Narakas // Revue médicale de la Suisse romande. — 1989. — Vol. 109. — P. 545–556.
  47. Narakas A. Clinical examination: Traumatic brachial plexus injuries / A. Narakas, C. Bonnard / J.-Y. Alnot and A.O. Narakas [editors]. — Paris: Expansion Scientifique Française, 1996. — P. 53–64.
  48. Narakas A. Les Paralysies suprascapulaires totales ; 1. Possibilités chirurgicales et résultats: Paralysies du plexus brachial / A. Narakas, Y. Allieu, J.-Y. Alnot [et al.] / J.-Y. Alnot et A.O. Narakas [editors]. — Paris: Expansion Scientifique Française, 1989. — P. 130–161.
  49. Narakas A.O. 1993 (communication personelle).
  50. Neer II Ch.S. Shoulder Reconstruction / Ch.S. Neer II. — Philadelphia; W.B. Saunders Company, 1990. — 551 с.
  51. Neviaser R.J. Concurrent Rupture of the Rotator Cuff and Anterior Dislocation of the Shoulder in the Older Patient / R.J. Neviaser, Th.J. Neviaser, J.S. Neviaser // J. Bone Jt. Surg. — 1988. — Vol. 70-A. — P. 1308–1311.
  52. Neviaser R.J. Anterior dislocation of the shoulder and rotator cuff rupture / R.J. Neviaser, T.J. Neviaser, J.S. Neviaser // Clin. Orthop. — 1993. — Vol. 291. — P. 103–106.
  53. Nishijima N. The swallow-tail sign: a test of deltoid function / N. Nishijima, T. Yamamuro, K. Fujio [et al.] // J. Bone Jt. Surg. — 1994. Vol. 77-B. — P. 152–153.
  54. Park J.-Y. Open intramedullary nailing with tension band and locking sutures for proximal humeral fracture: Hot air balloon technique / J.-Y. Park, J.-W. An, J.-H. Oh. // J. Shoulder Elbow Surg. — 2006. — Vol. 15, №5. — P. 594–601.
  55. Patte D. Luxations traumatiques de l’épaule. Encycl. Méd. Chir. / D. Patte. — Paris. Appareil locomoteur, 14037 C10, 4. — 1980. — P. 1–10.
  56. Prudnikov O.E. Lésions simultanées de la coiffe des rotateurs et du plexus brachial / O.E. Prudnikov // Rev. Chir. Orthop. — 1994. — Vol. 80. — P. 602–609.
  57. Prúdnikov O.E. Roturas del manguito rotador asociadas con la parálisis del deltoides. Cien años de errores evitables / O.E. Prúdnikov, E.E. Prúdnikov, D.O. Prúdnikov // Rev Cubana Ortop. Traumatol. — 2007. — Vol. 21(1).
  58. Radin E.L. Biomechanics and Functional Anatomy / E.L. Radin // The Shoulder. Surgical and Nonsurgical Management [Ed. by Melvin Post]. — Second edition. Lea & Febiger: Philadelphia, 1988. — P. 54–60.
  59. Richards R.R. Shoulder Arthrodesis for the Treatment of Brachial Plexus Palsy: A Review of 32 Patients / R.R. Richards, R.M.P. Sherman, A.R. Hudson [et al.] // Surgery of the Shoulder. M. Post, B.F. Morrey, R.J. Hawkins [editors]. — St. Louis: Mosby Year Book, 1990. — P. 334–342.
  60. Ries M.D. Biomechanics of the Shoulder / M.D. Ries // Principles of Orthopaedic Practice. Vol. I. / R. Dee, E. Mango, L.C. Hurst [eds.] — New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1989. — P. 511–515.
  61. Roper B.A. Restoration of function following paralysis of the deltoid and spinati / B.A. Roper, D. Brooks // J. Bone Jt. Surg. — 1972. — Vol. 54-B. — P. 172.
  62. Rowe C.R. Arthrodesis of the Shoulder Used in Treating Painful Condition / C.R. Rowe // Clin. Orthop. — 1983. — Vol. 173. — P. 92–96.
  63. Saha A.K. Surgery of the paralyzed and flail shoulder / A.K. Saha // Acta Orthop. Scand. — 1967. — Vol. 97. — P. 5–90.
  64. Simonich S.D. Terrible triad of the shoulder / S.D. Simonich, Th.W. Wright // J. Shoulder Elbow Surg. — 2003. — Vol. 12. — P. 566–568.
  65. Solonen K.A. A Method for Reconstruction of the Rotator Cuff After Rupture / K.A. Solonen // Shoulder Surgery. Ian Bayley and Lipmann Kessel [editors]. — Berlin-New York: Springer-Verlag, 1982. — P. 45–48.
  66. Staples O.S. Full active abduction in traumatic paralysis of the deltoid / O.S.Staples, A.L. Watkins // J. Bone Jt. Surg. — 1943. — XXV. — P. 85–89.
  67. Steinmann S.P. Nerve lesions / S.P. Steinmann, R.J. Spinner // The Shoulder [edited by Ch.A. Rockwood, F.A. Matsen III, M.A. Wirth, S.B. Lippit]. — 3d edition. Saunders: Philadelphia, 2004. — P. 1009–1031.
  68. Stöhr M. Läsionen der Nerven des Schultergurtels / M. Stöhr // Neurologie in Praxis und Klinik [herausgegeben von H.Ch. Hopf, K. Poeck, H. Schliak. Band III]. — Georg Thiеme Verlag: Stuttgart, 1993. — S. 6.87–6.88.
  69. Vastamäki M. Shoulder arthrodesis for paralysis and arthrosis / M. Vastamäki // Acta Orthop. Scand. — 1987. — Vol. 55. — P. 549–553.
  70. Visser C.P.J., Coene L.N.J.E.M., Brand R., Tavy D.L.J. The incidence of nerve injury in anterior dislocation of the shoulder and its influence on functional recovery / C.P.J. Visser, L.N.J.E.M. Coene, R. Brand [et al.] // J. Bone Joint Surg [Br]. — 1999. — Vol. 81-B. — P. 679–685.
  71. Watson M.S. Surgical Disorders of the Shoulder // M.S. Watson [editor]. — Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 1991. — P. 29–38.
  72. Werner C.M. Effect of experimental suprascapular nerve block on active glenohumeral translations in vivo / C.M. Werner, D. Weishaupt, S. Blumenthal [et al.] // J. Orthop. Res. — 2006. — Vol. 24 (3). — P. 491–500.
  73. Werner C.M.L. Subacromial pressures in vivo and effects of selective experimental suprascapular nerve block / C.M.L. Werner, S. Blumenthal, A. Curt [et al.] // J. Shoulder Elbow Surg. — 2006. — Vol. 15. — P. 319–323.
  74. Wiater J.M., Kippe M., Novinsky G.P. Surgical Treatment of Displaced Proximal Humerus Fractures with a Short Intramedullary Nail: 23rd Open Meeting of the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons, San Diego, California, February 17, 2007. — P. 44.
  75. Wright II Ph.E. Peripheral Nerve Injuries. Volume Four. / Ph.E.Wright II, M.T. Jobe // Campbell’s Operative Orthopaedics [Edited by A.H. Crenshaw]. — Eighth Edition. Mosby Year Book, 1992. — P. 2253–2254.

Downloads

How to Cite

Prudnikov, O., Prudnikov, Y., & Prudnikov, D. (2009). A complication of the rotator cuff with superior humeral paralyses: a myth of the deltoid muscle and the mechanics of the humeroscapular joint. ORTHOPAEDICS TRAUMATOLOGY and PROSTHETICS, (2), 108–116. https://doi.org/10.15674/0030-598720092108-116

Issue

No. 2 (2009)

Section

DISCUSSIONS, SEARCH, HYPOTHESES

License

Copyright (c) 2014 Oleg Prudnikov, Yevgeny Prudnikov, Dmitriy Prudnikov

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

The authors retain the right of authorship of their manuscript and pass the journal the right of the first publication of this article, which automatically become available from the date of publication under the terms of Creative Commons Attribution License, which allows others to freely distribute the published manuscript with mandatory linking to authors of the original research and the first publication of this one in this journal.

Authors have the right to enter into a separate supplemental agreement on the additional non-exclusive distribution of manuscript in the form in which it was published by the journal (i.e. to put work in electronic storage of an institution or publish as a part of the book) while maintaining the reference to the first publication of the manuscript in this journal.

The editorial policy of the journal allows authors and encourages manuscript accommodation online (i.e. in storage of an institution or on the personal websites) as before submission of the manuscript to the editorial office, and during its editorial processing because it contributes to productive scientific discussion and positively affects the efficiency and dynamics of the published manuscript citation (see The Effect of Open Access).